Unraveling the Mystery of John Stewart of Ashen Swamp
In genealogy, much of the journey involves sorting through names, places, and dates—often with the goal of ruling out people who aren’t part of your family tree. It’s a process of elimination that can be both exciting and frustrating. This has certainly been the case with my research on John Stewart of Ashen Swamp.
At first glance, John Stewart of Ashen Swamp seemed like a perfect candidate for my ancestor, John Stewart Sr. He lived in the right place at the right time, but after digging deeper into the records, I came to the conclusion that this John Stewart is not my ancestor. Still, his name, location, and time period overlap so closely with my own research that distinguishing between the two has been quite the challenge.
The Land and Social Circle of John Stewart of Ashen Swamp
One approach I used to separate these two John Stewarts was to map out the social network of John Stewart of Ashen Swamp. Through land patents and wills, certain surnames kept surfacing alongside his: Walthall, Ballow, Ward, and Ligon. I came to realize that when I saw one of these names in a record, it likely related to John Stewart of Ashen Swamp, not my John Stewart Sr.
The first mention of John Stewart of Ashen Swamp in colonial Virginia appears in 1672:
15 March 1672. John Stewart, for 600 acres beginning at a great branch of ye Ashen Swamp, where the orphans of William Walthall, their head line extendeth, etc.
For context, Ashen Swamp, now known as Ashton Creek, flows off the Appomattox River. What I find particularly intriguing is that many of the street names in this area still reflect the Walthall name—a prominent colonial family who were John Stewart of Ashen Swamp’s neighbors.
The Stewart Family of Ashen Swamp
John Stewart (1634–1706) of Ashen Swamp was married to first Dorothy Waters and second to Susannah Hatcher. He had at least two sons, Daniel (1670–1737) and John (1699–1784). This family connection is made clear in a 1697 deed:
30 September 1697. John Bowman witnesses deed of gift from John Stewart, Jr. for love and affection to my brother Daniel Stewart, with good will, discretion and order of my dear and honorable father John Stewart, Sr., the land now in possession of my father, bounded by William Walthall near Pride’s Path, from death of my father and Dorothy his wife; wit: also Samuel Newman and Nich. Dison; signed John Stewart, Jr.; rec. 1 Dec 1698 [Wills, Deeds, etc. 1697-1704, p. 130]
This deed, along with others, paints a picture of the Stewart family’s land holdings in the Ashen Swamp area. The family’s land appears again in John Stewart’s (1634–1714) will:
Will of John Stewart of Henrico County; To son John, 3 parcels of land: 200 acres at Ashen Swamp, 450 acres on south side of Branches Creek, 500 acres at Lily Valley, and items, to be given him at age 21. To daughter Sarah Stewart, part of a piece of land in dispute with Walthall and myself, next to Featherston’s line and Items, at age 16 or marriage. To youngest three daughters: Michal, Mary, and Judith Stewart, items, and part of the above land at age 16. To son John other lands above the Run, part of the lands in dispute. One third part of my goods etc. to wife Michal and rest equally divided between my children when of age. Also to wife, slaves and she to be executrix.; rec. 2 August 1714 [page 281, Henrico County Court]
Interestingly, John Stewart Jr.’s wife, Michal Ballow, likely brought the Lily Valley land as part of her dowry. The will mentions only 200 acres of land at Ashen Swamp, suggesting that perhaps the rest had been given to his brother Daniel in the earlier deed of gift.
John Stewart Jr.’s wife Michal passed away in 1719, and her will provides further insight into the family:
18 July 1719. I give to defend title to my land, to be in hands of my executor until children of age My son to have 2 years schooling and remain with Executor until 21 To daughter Sarah Steward, a black trunk To daughter Mary Steward, amber necklace To daughter Judith Steward, my silver tumbler To son John Steward, my purse and his father’s silver buttons therein Rest of estate divided between all my children. My brother Charles Ballew to be sole executor. Wit: Constant Perkins, John Ellis Sr., Drusilla Ballew; rec. 7 September 1719 at Henrico County, VA. [page 441, Henrico Court]
After this generation, the Stewart line in Ashen Swamp seems to have faded. John Stewart III died without an heir, and the administration of his estate in 1760 was handled by his sisters, Mary and Sarah, along with his brother-in-law James Ligon:
December 1760. Ct. Leonard Wood, Mary Stewart, and James Ligon granted adm of est. of John Stewart, Sarah Ward, by letter to court having already rel right to adm the est. Nicholas Giles, Abraham Bailey, John Burton, and Thomas Perkins to appraise. Richard Poval, Samuel Hobson, John Baskerfield, and Henry Clay to appraise John Stewart’s est. in Cumberland Co. [Henrico Co. Ct Order Bk 1755-1762. Pg 483]
June 1761. On the petition of Sarah Ward & Mary Stuart, two of the coheiresses of John Stewart, deceased, who was surety for Judith Ligon, executrix of Joseph Ligon dec’d, and guardian to John Ligon, and who has since intermarried with James Ligon, complaining of mismanagement of the estate of the said Joseph (Ligon) and suggesting that they are in danger of suffering as representatives of the said John Stuart, else that they appear at next court to show cause why they may not do so. [Court, Chesterfield County, Order Book III, p 138]
A Possible Connection to John Stewart of Fighting Creek?
One last mystery remains. Some records suggest that John Stewart of Ashen Swamp may have had connections to Cumberland County, particularly in 1760, when his estate was being handled. This raises the question: What happened to the land in Cumberland County?
It’s possible that the John Stewart of Ashen Swamp mentioned in these records is the same person as John Stewart of Fighting Creek, who is known to have owned land in Cumberland County. However, the timelines don’t quite align, especially when a 1724 land transaction for Fighting Creek mentions both a John Stewart Sr. and John Stewart Jr. as adults. If John Stewart of Ashen Swamp’s father had already died by 1714, these two lines might be separate.
Another option is that these are two distinct families—the Ashen Swamp line ending with John Stewart III’s death without an heir, and the Fighting Creek line continuing with a different John Stewart. But that leaves the question of what happened to the Cumberland estate once tied to John Stewart of Ashen Swamp.
Conclusion
In genealogy, not every lead turns out to be a direct connection, but it can still offer valuable insight. In this case, John Stewart of Ashen Swamp may not be my ancestor, but understanding his family has helped me narrow down possibilities and avoid confusion with other John Stewarts in the area. The search continues for more definitive proof of my own John Stewart Sr., but each discovery—whether a connection or not—gets me one step closer to the truth.
Update: Subsequent research has clarified that the “orphan” John Stewart of Fighting Creek was John, son of John Stewart and Michal Ballow of the Ashen Swamp Stewart line. The Fighting Creek lands eventually passed to Benjamin Hatcher due to the Stewart–Hatcher connection through Susannah Hatcher, widow of William Hatcher, who later married John Stewart of this line. This means the Fighting Creek Stewarts are not related to the Amherst line I am researching. For full details, see my updated post.
Leave a Reply